[x]
All Deviations
[x]

So-called "Legalized Art theft"

Journal Entry: Mon Apr 14, 2008, 3:37 PM
it's just another social virus thats being spread through everyones little minds that this is something that exists today. Who ever started up this shit is either a complete idiot because they dont to research or is an even bigger idiot if they ignored that and decided to just spread un-true crap all over the internet.

of course its probably not your fault if you read this: [link]=pageone&article_no=3605&;page=1 because that's the guys fault for doing his own research

as quoted from [link]

"1. There was a bill about "Orphan Works" up before congress in 2006. This bill did deal with copyright and the treatment of "abandoned" works of art. The bill was not, however, being backed by Bill Gates, was not a plot between Bill Gates and the government to steal art or legalize art theft, and did not require artists to register their copyrights. (Requiring copyright registration is illegal.)

2. The actual subject of the bill was an attempted solution to the problem of orphaned art, art that has no owner, either because the owner has deliberately abandoned it, or because the owner is unknown. To simplify it, the bill was basically saying that if somebody finds a work of art, and makes every possible effort to locate and contact the original artist, and cannot do so, then they have a legal right to use that art, and cannot be taken to court for doing so. This has the potential for abuse, yes, but I really would prefer it, in that case, if people would discuss the real issue, and not the boondoggle of legalizing art theft, which was not the intended purpose of the bill at all.

3. The bill failed to pass.

4. There was a subcommittee hearing to consider a similar bill for this current session of congress, but it fizzled and nothing happened.

There is still some legitimate concern about this bill possibly turning up again; however, a.) the bill isn't nearly so awful as that article claims, and b.) it also may never come up again, while there ARE many bills that we ought to concern ourselves with that ARE currently being debated in congress.

I really dislike this sort of thing, and while I know that people who re-post these kinds of articles are very well meaning and just want to warn their friends, I honestly wish more people would research this kind of thing before passing it along just on the say-so of some guy on the internet. It causes so much concern and worry and wasted effort that could be spent on real issues and not on boogeymen.

First sources:
The text of the bill itself:
[link]
(You'll need to click the "continue to GPO site" link to get it.)


A report about the situation that inspired the bill from the US Copyright office:
[link]

I have seen one legit article mentioning the return of this bill, here:
[link]

However, the bill is NOT listed for the current session of congress.

[link] is where you can look up current legislation."



not saying I didnt believe it.... but obviously i didnt join the band wagon and start posting shit here on dA. I first talked to my dad about it, (him knowing MANY of the congressmen) and then told my dear friend ~Frikin-ChibiiconFrikin-Chibi: : about it, whom which did her homework. (Good Maria~ -pats-)




now you all post journals saying you're sorry for NOT doing your homework


just goes to show that the quote is true:

"When we assume it makes an 'ass' out of 'u' and 'me'."


I swear to god...

  • Mood: Disgust
  • Listening to: 10 years
  • Reading: God of War & Death Note

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0

~Frikin-Chibi:iconFrikin-Chibi: Apr 14, 2008, 3:41:06 PM
xD you must edit j00r journal

D:< I look up the crap before anyone else bothers to, wtf.

--
3G iPhone DS Killer?
HAH! I'd like to see it try!
*SilverFlameWanderer:iconSilverFlameWanderer: Apr 14, 2008, 3:48:56 PM
I love that quote.

--
SilverFlameWanderer~

Isn't faith believing all power can't be seen?
- Josh Groban
~caroro:iconcaroro: Apr 14, 2008, 3:58:59 PM
lol

--
Bring it.
~caroro:iconcaroro: Apr 14, 2008, 3:59:44 PM
because you smart >:E

and im editting it D:< stfu

--
Bring it.
*ShePaintsWithBlood:iconShePaintsWithBlood: Apr 14, 2008, 5:38:03 PM
This whole thing has gotten very dramatic ^o.o^ But I will not lie, I was very upset when I read the article. I had to get up early for work the next day so instead of doing the research I knew I should have, I went to bed...but luckily I found out more about it before I began ranting. The one good thing is, as another deviant pointed out to me, hopefully it made more people think about watermarking and signing their works so greedy art thieves would not be able to claim them as their own. But you cannot you cannot blame people for being scared. We all learned our lesson now, do some research. Just like with animal testing, before you decide if you like it or hate it, do some research +laughs+

Heheh, my aunt taught me that quote when I was rather young, it amused me greatly at the time.:blackrose:

--
Please help me make my ferret all better, buy some cheap prints or donate via Paypal to ShePaintsWithBlood@hotmail.com AND PLEASE PRAY! Pray for her to be alright. I am not ready to let my Cubby go yet.
Handsome icon by *helterskellter
*Kinky-Slingy:iconKinky-Slingy: Apr 14, 2008, 6:22:11 PM
mmmhmm i heard that 8D

--
Love is like a heroine addiction. The first time you taste it, you succumb to the rapture of the feeling, and you strive to obtain it evermore..
Skitterflits!
Live, Laugh, Love